I'd imagine most people (except maybe 3 or 4) won't read this because of its length, but no matter. It's still fun to throw out there.
I still can't quite grasp how I feel about the latest addition to the Twilight Saga. The fact that my opinion isn't strong either way says something. It says that this movie failed in being what it should have been: the best. It should have, at the very least, made me go..."Wow. Too awesome." Instead I was like, "Wow. Too....okay." But I do know that I neither truly loved it or truly hated it. I was good. Not great. Not horrible. Just good. It ought to have been more than what it was, but sadly, it wasn't. It is what it is. That is, until some many more years down the line someone tries it again. Hopefully I'll be alive to see it if that's the case!
Anyway, Eclipse is my favorite book of the whole series, followed closely by New Moon. Why do I have a fondness for Eclipse? A lot of things came into the light in this one, which is kinda ironic considering the title, but whatever. It's my favorite. I loved the development of the love triangle, the playfulness and scuffles of Bella and Jacob, the onslaught of new vampires, the alliance of the wolves with vampires, the action, just....everything. Now the movie? Sadly, the movie was missing a LOT of the juicy stuff from the book. A lot of stuff that, to me, was crucial in getting across the main point of the story at that level of the series. This was an extension of New Moon, or at least it should have been. It was the presentation of Bella realizing deep love for another man other than Edward.
Was this as bad as Twilight? Maybe not quite so much, but pretty damn close. There was just way too much missing that made it feel like Eclipse the book in movie form. I don't mind a few changes, and I expect lots to be left out, but come on...leaving important details out that contribute to the story? Not a fan of that, even if the scenes that WERE kept were well executed (for the most part).
So okay, the GOOD:
*SCORE*
Some people likely won't care about this part, but I'm gonna say it anyway. I totally loved the music in the movie this time around. Not the songs, the MUSIC. Twilight's score was great, but New Moon's was eh. And this time, it's great again in Eclipse. Thankfully, the composer from Lord of the Rings, Howard Shore, was involved with this one. It took me the two viewings of the movie to pay more attention to the music, since the first time around I was more focused on the characters, but once I started listening more carefully, I totally was falling for it. It has an ominous feel to it at the right points in the right amounts to make the movie feel a little more darker and more mature than its predecessors. Yes, the score junky that I am has discovered a new, desirable movie score to add to my collection. And it turns out my favorite music bit, which is sprinkled all throughout the movie in different forms, coincidentally is called "Jacob Black." I totally didn't know that until I started listening to the tracks, so I was pleasantly surprised. And that leads me to the next good thing about the movie...
*JACOB BLACK*
Being the team Jacob person that I am, it's fairly obvious that I would continue to love him to death in these movies. But I will keep saying it until I'm blue in the face. He's quite simply the most perfect character on screen. And I would imagine I'd feel the same if I wasn't a fan of him. I've said it before and I'll say it again, Taylor Lautner is still, in my opinion, the ONLY one who is putting all the effort he can into portraying the Jacob Black I read in the books. It is so obvious. His facial expressions and tone of voice, being perfect for the scenes he's present for. He freaking IS Jacob Black. I can't find one smidgen of anything that isn't right about him, other than certain lines and crucial scenes that are missing, which of course isn't Taylor's fault. But the missing dialog and scenes will be discussed later on in this blog. Oh what I wouldn't give to hear him say, "Sure, sure" as he always did in the book, but alas, that line looks like it'll never see the light of day in the movies. But everything about him is SO RIGHT. I've even forgiven his lack of height thing. You almost forget he's technically supposed to be way taller than Bella and even Edward, but Taylor certainly pulls off his character so well that you don't even care about that anymore. He's witty and funny (he had some of the best lines in the movie) stubborn and childish, walks around without his shirt, and even his wolf form is perfect, especially when he interacts with Bella a little bit to have her pet his head. Just....PERFECT.
*THE PROPOSAL*
Well executed I think, in which Edward finally officially proposes to Bella and she says yes. Now my memory sucks, but I'm not sure exactly WHEN that scene should have happened, and whether or not it was placed correctly in the movie, but still. I thought it went pretty well. But I gotta be honest...one of the main reasons I thought it was good is because I wanted to gag at the sappiness of it lol. So to speak. If it wasn't good or believable, I wouldn't roll my eyes in disgust at the result. I would have just watched it and been like, "Alrighty." But yeah, it was so beyond mushy and vomit-worthy so you know it had to be good to get that reaction out of me. And there you have it.
*THE FLASHBACKS*
Very appreciated. Eh, okay, there is also badness about Rosalie's flashback scene, but I'll get to that later. I was actually surprised that they were even in the movie. So it was definitely cool to see the histories of Jasper, Rosalie, and the wolves onscreen. I don't really have much to say on them, but they did their part and didn't bother me.
*THE PUNCH*
Quite perfect. That is, the punch from Bella after Jacob forcibly kisses her. I loved seeing that twit wince. Now the scene was totally shorter than it should have been, as well as lacked the line that would have been awesome to hear from Jacob Black afterwards in which he says, "Come on...that had to be better than kissing a rock." So it absolutely SUCKED not hearing any dialog after the punch. The main meat of the interaction was there, however. It would have been interesting to see the forced kiss to play out as it was described in the book, in which Bella tries to fight him off unsuccessfully and just stands there while he kisses her, but without kissing back. After she asks if he's done, that's when she punches him. But eh...I guess I could understand why they tweaked it a little. I think it makes it a little more dramatic to have her successfully push him off of her and then punch him, rather than draw it out longer as in the book. The punch was still there, as well as the pain she got. I'll tolerate it being a sprain instead of a cracked knuckle as in the book, since that's kinda minor and unimportant. It would have been great if she just dropped dead from it cuz she sucks anyway, but alright...that's just me dreaming.
*THE KISS*
That is, between Bella and Jacob. Pretty damn close to what I visualized in the book, right down to the intensity of it and even the movements of the characters. Now in the book, that huge kiss between those two was like 4 pages long, and practically every little detail was described, right down to hands and even the ears. Yes, the ears. It made all of the kisses with Edward pale in comparison, which was supposed to be the point. In the book, it was the defining moment that snapped Bella out of her denial of being in love with Jacob too. So their kiss had to play out perfectly with just the right amount of passion that would scream to Bella that she loves Jacob. And I believe this played out well on the big screen. I mean sure, there were other parts missing that I believe made it even more intense in the book, but it probably wouldn't have worked in movie form. Like, at first, Bella wasn't really into it, and that's when Jake was all, "Are you sure "Are you sure you want me to come back; or do you really want me to die?" Bella gets mad, blah, blah, blah, but eventually...she started kissing him back like....INTENSELY. That stuff worked in the book, which is probably why it was a few pages long, but in the movie, I would imagine it would have been frustrating to see so many "interruptions" to the BIG moment of having their first real kiss. So eh, I was able to deal. And as I mentioned earlier, there was still that little moment where Jacob gave her one more peck before walking away, which was just as sweet as described in the book. It was an awesome kiss, and I actually did like Bella's reaction afterward. Kristen very much sucks at being Bella, but she did manage to pull off the whole, "Oh my God...I love him" look when the kiss was over. Probably because it only involves staring blankly into space, which she does perfectly anyway.
*CHARLIE AND RENEE*
Any scene with Charlie was priceless. Almost TOO good. I just wish he was in the movie a lot more. Loved, loved, LOVED the "virgin talk" scene. In fact, that was probably the best acting I've seen Kristen do. She made it believable and was even, dare I say, a little funny. "Okay Dad? I'm a virgin," and then...thumbs up! Hehe it was funny and just as awkward a moment on-screen as it was in the book. A very much human moment and so very cute. Renèe's scene as well was actually very endearing. I forget the actress who plays Renèe, but she's actually very good at bringing Bella's mom to life. She so....mom-like during her scene with Bella and personally, I found it to be absolutely flawless. You really start believing the reality of the situation, of Renèe being so oblivious to what will befall her daughter. The only gripe I had was Bella's lack of tears. What the hell does Kristen have against squeezing out some liquid out of those eyes of hers? I mean damn.
*WOLVES (human and animal)*
I don't feel they were maximized as much as I wanted them to be, but their presence and fight scenes were satisfactory. Their human forms were fun too, but again....too minimally used. Leah was just as bitterly angry as in the book. PERFECT. I can't wait to see her expand her role. But their small scenes were still well executed. I loved when they picked on Jacob about Bella. It sorta was like the icing on the cake in seeing them interact like siblings. Very cute. I would have loved to see them do that whole "sniffing the Cullens" thing to get used to their scent just for the sake of interactions, but that's pretty minor. They had great scenes, great visuals, great sound effects, etc. I loved Jacob standing nearby Bella so she can pat his head. That seemed to really invoke what they had (or at least should have had) with each other, even when he was in wolf form. And Seth was unbelievably adorable, human and wolf alike. ADORABLE, I say. I want a pet Seth wolf of my own. Like now.
*THE CULLENS*
But ONLY in the sense of seeing them be more of who they are. I like seeing them expand as characters, at least most of them. Some of them, their overall look was major fail, but some parts still worked. I thought the contacts looked better for some reason. Rosalie had a better wig, but omg, what happened to her face? Too much makeup and she looked a little ridiculous. But her bratty attitude was still intact, which was great. Esme's hair was yuck. Change it back. Jasper's hair always annoyed me since the beginning, so whatever. I liked Alice's vision stuff, seeing it from her perspective. Everyone's characters were very well done.
*EMMETT*
Perfecto! He deserves an honorable mention all his own. Pretty much the best Cullen with the best lines, such as, "Trying to chew gum and walk at the same time again, Bella?" Totally different line than from the book, which was something along the lines of, "Fall down again, Bella?" But that was very much acceptable because it was still so hilarious. His brawn was perfect too. Emmett, along with Jacob, were pretty much the most spot-on main characters.
*RILEY'S GANG*
It was good ONLY in the sense that it brought Bree's book to life somewhat, and sorta introduced us to her so we can get somewhat attached to her innocence. It made me want to see her interaction with Diego, Fred, and others. However...HOWEVER!! What should have been done is to give Bree her own little mini movie as an extra disc (or special feature) on the dvd/blu-ray release, and not include it in this movie, at least at the expense of what was missing that truly was in "Eclipse." It wasn't horrible, but alas, seeing as how this movie focused too MUCH on Riley's army of newborns instead of what was REALLY in the book, then it was bad. Very bad. I will vent on that later. I felt it deserved a mention, though.
*THE FIGHT*
It was a little fast for my taste, but as I ponder the book's version, you don't get to "see" ANY of that battle, other than whatever Edward said. So I did like that they showed us, the audience, what was going on, while at the same time having Edward relay it. That worked for me. Can't say I'm crazy about the weird glass sound effects as vampire parts got ripped off, but it's nothing major. I was one of people who actually loved the blur effects from "New Moon," so I really missing seeing that in "Eclipse," but oh well. And the wolves looked amazing. The scene, though short-lived, was impressive to watch.
*BREE*
Very cute. Dunno who the actress is, but I'd say she personified Bree's childlike innocence pretty good. However, her character's impact was brutally butchered down. More on that in the bad list. I did, however, like that it was Esme to try and defend Bree instead of Edward. Very motherly to do, and honestly, I would have expected her to say it more than Edward anyway. So I thought it worked better than it would have if Edward had said it as in the book.
*FUNNY LINES*
At least the ones that made it into the movie, anyway, were freaking hilarious. The most obvious that even Team Edward people can appreciate was Jacob's "Let's face it; I am hotter than you." Because you know it's true! In at least one sense. Oh it was perfect. I cheered aloud in the theater along with other Team Jacob fans scattered around when I heard that line. And he says it so...so casually like he, Edward, and the viewing audience knows that what he says is FACT lol. Edward had his moment too which his, "Doesn't he own a shirt?" line, which was pretty fitting I'd say hehe. I'm certain plenty of Team Edwardians wondered the same thing. Though you can't deny Jacob looks great without his shirt.
And now for the BAD.
*ROSALIE'S FLASHBACK*
Okay, it was great seeing it, but to have Bella go to Rosalie to learn this story is...blah. It just wasn't right. In the book, it was Rosalie who goes to Bella to tell her story. Why is it a big deal? Because to me, it was the one perfect moment that showed a different side to Rosalie, a somewhat more tender side than what we've gotten accustomed to. Oh sure, her shell still sorta cracked a little, but the effect of it just wasn't the same. It was Rosalie's willingness to explain herself to someone as minor as Bella, which she was always seemingly so opposed to, that gave the scene that much more impact in the book. It was somewhat of a "shocker" and you immediately wonder why Rosalie would be willing to have an actual conversation with the likes of trivial Bella. You think, "Hmmm....Rosalie WANTS to talk to Bella? Since when? Interesting!" But having Bella go to Rosalie was so....just eh. It came off as Bella making the effort in fixing things between the two when it was really Rosalie.
*BELLA*
Oh...my...GAWD. Somebody please gauge my eyes out so I don't have to witness this travesty on the screen. What an absolute disgrace. I would still like to just....smack her. She wasn't all that bad in "New Moon." Though I still hated that she doesn't shed a tear for anything. I didn't think it could get worse than that. But alas, it does. Kristen managed to make me crave the Bella of the book, and I HATE book Bella. But good grief, can I get someone who can properly EMOTE when the scene doesn't call for loud, sporadic outbursts? At least book Bella--despite her AWFUL tendency to overly whine and pout--still gives me the impression that she gives a damn about stuff. But Kristen's Bella is a horrible at emoting, at least during the calmer, less stressful scenes. You don't feel like she cares about anything way too often. How is she so fantastic as people say? I get the whole loner, weirdo thing. And to have this lone, weirdo be the ultimate magnet to very loyal guys who love her despite her obscurities, well...that's just fine. What girl wouldn't want that? But to not have a personality to go along with it? Kristin's Bella does not have this. What in the WORLD does ANYONE see in this version of Bella? Edward, Jacob, and heck...even MIKE NEWTON? I just don't see it. She's not even interesting. Making Bella this sort of girl, this loner without a slight taste of being just a little bit feminine (in the emotional way), destroys the spirit of the book later on when it's depicted in these movies. It's a horrible thing watching all these scenes in which she's supposed to be tearing up, hurting, or showing some deep-set emotion just fizzle into meaninglessness because Kristen can't express them properly. She has the exact same expression in almost every scene. I can only take so much jaw-gaping and mindless staring. Give me something else because that doesn't work for me anymore (if it ever did). I'm not saying give me the crybaby Bella from the book, but something in between would be GREAT.
Not only are her expression similar, but many things she says sound exactly the same as everything else. There are a number of shining moments that Kristin's a master at pulling off, but Bella is supposed to be more than that. This time around, nothing seems to faze or affect her. During one scene, Edward tells her rather callously, as in the book, that everyone she knows will be dead in a few decades and her problem is solved. So what does movie Bella do? Cringe? Cry a little? Maybe sighs in discontentment? Of course not! This is Kristin Stewart's girl-power Bella. Stuff like that doesn't bother her. She just brushed that off and continued on talking like he didn't say anything that stung her a little. Book Bella at least flinched at his words, something Edward picked up on and apologized for it being harsh. She should have sighed and hesitantly agreed. In the movie, NONE OF THAT. Another time is when Charlie asks if she recalls his reason for grounding her, and all I get is a very somber, yawn-worthy, "Yeah I put you through hell." Like she's bored or maybe secretly going la-dee-da in her head. Was it so difficult to have her...oh I don't know, give a long drawn out sigh while saying something like, "Yeah...I just...*sigh* well, I put you through hell." Because at least then it might SEEM that she feels just a tad bit bad. She has this whole, "Well whatever" attitude throughout a good portion of this movie, that it's actually extremely irritating. I almost wonder if something was just wrong with Kristin the entire time. She's so monotone most of the time, lacking dimensional depth. What it seems like they were going for is to make Bella this stronger, semi-independent, mini feminist of sorts who doesn't let her emotions govern her sometimes, AS BELLA SHOULD BE. Scenes where she's supposed to be vulnerable and a victim of her imperfections are now scenes of her seemingly proudly emanating how oh so strong she is despite them. The scene when Jacob overhears Edward and Bella speak of marriage was very wrong for many reasons, one of which is because when Edward tries to pull her back from going to him, she snaps a curt "Don't!" to him and flashes him a pissed off look. Bella would never fathom talking down to Edward. She was all about beating herself up more than beating Edward up. Oh, but wait, this is strong and feisty Bella, so let's not have her feel bad about anything because...you guessed it, GIRL POWER!! Why have her feel hurt over hurting the men in her life? Why have her cry? She's Feministawoman! With bad hair. That wig was disgusting. UGHHHHHH.
*JACOB AND BELLA*
Remember Edward's overprotective, controlling efforts that totally turned him into...well...somewhat of a jerk? Or the "kidnapping?" Remember all the sneaking around by Bella and Jacob? Or Bella hanging out with Jacob against Edward's wishes or all the phone calls between the two, or basically all the moments when their friendship grows to an unstoppable level, one in which their LOVE can be more believable, more solidified between the two? Remember pretty much EVERYTHING that happened between the ridiculous transitions of all the scenes from the film? Hah, well in the movie, NONEXISTENT. If you haven't read the book, let me enlighten you. At the end of New Moon, the book, Bella says goodbye to Jacob, turning around just in time to see his face "crumple in pain." And then at the beginning of Eclipse, you get sight of a letter written by Jacob commenting on Bella's futile attempts to contact him again. Charlie informs her of Jacob going through a hard time, which triggers Bella's desire to fix things. She wants to visit Jacob, but Edward continually stops her, citing the danger of the wolves. And he sticks with this mindset for a great deal of time, which causes rebellion from Bella, so to speak. She does whatever she can to see her friend, making you believe that she really does love him in her way. But in the movie, you're like...oh, they're still best friends? Well you'd be lucky to realize this. Why? Because they don't explore it. After what they had Bella say to him at the end of "New Moon," (lines that still piss me off..."I love you, but don't make me choose, because it's Edward and it's always been Edward, which means you NEVER stood a chance") you can't imagine why he'd want to still try. Perhaps that's what they were going for this time around, except...it doesn't work! It ruins the flow of where the series is supposed to go. So perhaps if these movie makers, oh I don't know...SHOW THEM SPENDING TIME TOGETHER, it might have helped me believe that he's truly the other corner on this supposed love triangle. I might have believed that Jacob's heavy interest in her and Bella's heavy insistence of being around him could have sprouted a true threat to the relationship between Bella and Edward. If only they didn't shy away from this. Yes, this was more explored in "New Moon," the friendship angle, but "Eclipse" was meant to explore something beyond friendship into the realm of love. But you never believe the love part.
The two of them ought to have been holding hands, joking, laughing. Jacob ought to have been misbehaving, and Bella complaining. There ought to have been more squabbling between the two, some sort of comfort level that could help materialize their own love. There ought to have been Jacob screwing up badly, and apologizing profusely later on, not IN THE SAME SCENE like with him and Bella in his garage. I suppose they tried to hurry things along, but what the heck for? These movies can be 4 hours long and I GUARANTEE you, they'll still make a killing. Anyway, they both were supposed to be ever so stubborn towards each other, prodding each other, yet forgiving each other....overlooking whatever problems arise between them. Sadly, the movie didn't have much of this, if any. Oh...she's supposed to be pushy about spending time with him when Edward was even pushier about NOT letting that happen? I had no idea! Why is that? Ah...cuz Edward didn't stop her beyond the one minor time of messing up her truck. After that small attempt, Bella had a remarkably easy time seeing Jacob, almost as if it was a casual, uninterrupted desire, something Edward wasn't even trying to stop for whatever reason. So she got to see him with no problem like it's...well, not a problem, and still not showing emotion at all! Yay! I totally believe that Jacob's someone she loves! UGH. Seriously, there is no life between Bella and her supposed best friend Jacob. They're in love? REALLY? That wasn't just sort of obligatory mimicry of friendship they had? Because that's what it looked like on the screen to me. It seemed that Jacob was stubbornly infatuated with a stone cold boring statue. Yes, he's stubborn in the book, but that's his character. He's SUPPOSED to be stubborn and immature. But without Bella emoting in any fashion towards him in return, save for one or two tiny moments, you don't get the feeling that she cares about him, not even in the friendship sort of way. She almost seems annoyed by him. So you find yourself shaking your head at Jacob, wondering why he doesn't get that this girl isn't that into him. And that's NOT the way you're supposed to be feeling towards Jacob or towards the two of them; I don't care how team Edward you are. You're supposed to FEEL their relationship, how it's not a minor thing. In the book, Bella makes every effort she can in seeing her friend, no matter the price. In the movie, it's all..."yeah whatever." Jacob is supposed to sneak to her school to "kidnap" Bella from Alice's presence, since Alice cannot see his future, and that's when Bella should have ridden off with him on his bike. She is supposed to "rebel" against Edward, still loving him, but loving Jacob too. I SEE NONE OF THAT IN THIS MOVIE. Oh she rode off with Jacob alright, but in the presence of Edward? That was a blatant slap to his face, which I hate to say this...is so NOT Bella, but it IS this movie version of girl-power Bella. I really missed the interactions between Bella and Jacob in this movie. I truly did. They really screwed up this time.
*SCENE TRANSITIONS*
Fast and randomly placed. Even boring. Some of them are way too jumpy from scene to scene, leaving no believable fluidity. Most seemed like such cop-outs. One major chunk of movie with too-quick scenes stemmed out from the whole Riley in Bella's house scene. One minute he's in the house snooping, staring down Billy, and the next...in walks Bella and Billy's awake and walking around talking about dinnertime! Then suddenly Edward is at the door, picks up on the scent, then it's jump straight to the Cullen house. Then poof, it's daytime and Jacob's coming out of her house critiquing the scent too. They have a mini alliance to guard Bella, and night quickly comes and goes. Poof to the daytime, and the one and only moment when Edward dropped Bella off to Jacob, Jacob asks, "What do you wanna do?" followed by a short list of suggestions. With no response from Bella (surprise, surprise!), Jacob says they're going to a party that night, and then POOF!! On to the nighttime "party" scene. It was all a total of maybe 6 minutes long. In fact, I'm willing to bet it's 6 minutes if not less. Let me time it.....
Yep. Literally 5 minutes, from Riley's snooping scene to Jake and Bella walking to the bonfire scene. Five freaking minutes. Adding even another mere 5 more minutes could have made all the difference. I do not understand the freaking rush.
Where's all the interactions that lead up to this scene? Stuff like that could have contributed to the Bella/Edward and Jacob/Bella relationships. Now in the book, everything is pretty much the same, just more drawn out, and we have the convenience of having a bloody scene to make things interesting. BLOOD! But noooo, there's no place for that in the movie. Oyy. Now what should have happened was after Riley's snooping they go to the Cullen's to discuss the matter, and Bella even nearly begs for them to change her to a vampire then, so as not to put Charlie in danger from the mysterious visitor again. This fails, of course, and the NEXT DAY, they decide to call Jacob over to analyze the scent himself. And during his visit, he complains of smell, he jokes with Bella, etc. Then he accidentally stabs himself with a knife after finding out Bella's planned graduation transformation. (Nope, he didn't hear of this in the garage as the movie shows). Anyway, he gets blood all over the place because the gash is DEEP, and this is when Bella witnesses his rapid healing first-hand. I would've loved to see that too. Eventually, he politely asks if Bella can come to his side of town for that "party" scene, which took place on a mountain top, not in their backyard. And he didn't just throw her right into the party scene as they had him do in the movie. There was just so much more thought that should have been placed in the movie's translation of these scenes, even if they WERE shortened for timing's sake. And the thought just wasn't there.
*RILEY'S GANG/NEWBORNS*
They so should NOT have had the focus in this movie. I've covered the good of them, but there's more bad than good here. I can appreciate seeing things from a non-Bella perspective, especially seeing as how she's an uninteresting wooden board anyway, but not at the expense of what was truly in the book. The previously mentioned stuff I just talked about is the perfect example of what suffered just so these scenes can exist. If they wanted to keep Riley and his newborns in this movie, fine, but do NOT take away from the book's TRUE scenes, scenes that could have added to the core of the story on the big screen. Add in another half hour to the movie, keep Riley AND most of the crucial book scenes, and then EVERYONE can be happy. But unfortunately, to accommodate his side of the story, which wasn't in the book, stuff had to be sacrificed. I don't care about focusing on what Victoria's trying to do to kill Bella. I liked not knowing. Hell, even I want to kill her. But what I DO and would have LOVED to care about was everything else BESIDES the newborns. I loved them, don't get me wrong, but I loved the other stuff more. In the book, there was more mystery about the Seattle killings, and I liked that. But in the movie, it's immediately thrown in your face Riley's transformation. It was a great scene, but blah, it just didn't belong there. Not at the beginning of the movie, at least. It was even odd to see Victoria interacting with him. I just liked it being mysterious.
*MISSING DIALOGUE*
Nothing major here, just my own little pouting preference. One line I would have loved to hear was from Edward. "If I'd never left, you wouldn't feel the need to go risk your life to comfort a dog." He says it to deter Bella from visiting Jacob, and it somewhat upsets her. It was a line that depicts a little bit of Edward's cold side (emotionally speaking). Even Jacob's, "Does my being half-naked bother you?" line would have been great to hear, but that's probably because I remember an interview with Taylor Lautner when he said he would love to say that line. But alas, there are three big screw-ups when it comes to dialog, or lack thereof.
*VICTORIA*
Eh....yes, I missed the original actress. I thought Bryce did a good job in her way, but I'm too accustomed to the other Victoria. People have been saying it everywhere, but Bryce is just way too cutesy and soft to portray an enraged, vengeful vampire. The psychotic nature of her was so well done in the first two films. This one left me wanting more. I love Bryce to death, but come on. Couldn't the creators of this film just get over themselves and keep the original actress? They should have known the fans wouldn't like a change. I suppose Victoria was always meant to be very Bryce-like, by the book's description (her voice was alwyas meant to be high-strung and angelic, after all) which is fine if that's what we had since the beginning, but that wasn't the case. And I would imagine all of her scenes would have been 10 times better if it was the same Victoria from the first two films. Oh, and her hair was atrocious. Bryce is a natural redhead; it could not have been that difficult to utilize this without a nasty-looking wig.
*COLD BELLA/TENT SCENE*
Minor yes, but still. Horrible! Well not in totality, but they couldn't make her lips blue or give her a little bit of ice breath? I wasn't convinced she was cold at all. It just looked like exaggerating acting to me. As I said, so very minor, but come on. It couldn't have been hard to pull off. They could have even had Jacob's stubborn line of, "You're lips are still blue; want me to take of that for you too? You only have to ask."
*THE END*
By far the most disappointing. Bear with me as I give out my final spew.
- Conclusion of the fight scene between Victoria and Edward. It was actually pretty well done for the most part, but I didn't care for anyone's reactions after it was all said and done. Bella never cut herself in the book, but I can understand why they did it in the movie. It was forgivable, I suppose, but it sorta cheapened the weight of the scene. Seth was supposed to have faked being hurt, which caused Bella to seriously ponder stabbing herself, but Edward and Seth still managed to finish the fight. After Edward decapitated Victoria, he approaches Bella very cautiously because he took note of her holding the sharp object very tightly. He thought she was fearful of him because she was frozen in place, and wonders why she wasn't bothered about the decapitation and dismemberment. The fight was meant to FEEL over until Edward gasps and starts speaking as one of the wolves. Bella was never meant to see Jacob getting hurt, but was supposed to have that relayed to her via Edward. I can forgive that. It added a dose of drama to have her view Jacob getting hurt, instead of just hearing about it, though her lack of tears totally didn't help the situation. What I truly hated was not seeing Edward and Seth gathering vampire chunks and giving each other a sort of "high five," nose to fist as the book depicts. Edward saying "Nice teamwork" would have helped too, seeing as how their camaraderie is only just beginning. So it sucked not to see more closeness between them. I'm guessing it wasn't done because it was too "friendly." Bah!
- Dialog before Bella and Jacob's big kiss. In the book, she does indeed practically beg him to stay. But one important factor that was missing was Bella giving in to expressing the love she had for him, even if he was being manipulative to get her to confess. In the book, she apologizes profusely for hurting him, telling him she wished she didn't meet him just so didn't have to keep hurting him. She literally begs him to stay, telling him that they can compromise, that maybe she'll change her mind, that she'll give him anything he wants. In a sort of pouty way, Jacob slips out another "I love you" to her. And that's when she finally, FINALLY, tells him the same. He then says, "I know that better than you do." I WOULD HAVE SO LOVED TO HEAR THAT. Fast-forward a bit and they finally kiss, a kiss that sealed the deal for Bella, a kiss that proved to her what she was feeling all along. I mean, the entire scene was so important a moment that helped Bella realize what she truly felt, and of course, it was breezed right through in the movie. She doesn't say anything about not wanting to lose him, or that he's too important, as the movie depicts. What they could have had her say that would have been more true to the scene was "Because I love you" when Jacob asked why he should stay I could have forgiven that. But there wasn't anything! Nothing about her loving him. But because they didn't pursue this, I don't feel like her decision will sway at all, or that she's somewhat torn over him. In fact, it feels like she's just trying to get a kiss out of him before he goes to die. I don't understand why this scene had to be missing that element. It was all meant to make the final moment between them at the end of the movie make more sense. Why? When Jacob was lying there on the bed, he claims he got her to admit her feelings to him. And unless you read the book, you might find yourself thinking, "Um, when was that?" I personally don't see HOW one could agree that she admitted her feelings in the movie's version of it all. There was just a little bit of begging on Bella's part without any utterance of love, and then there was the kiss. A perfect kiss, yes, but still. A passionate "goodbye" kiss isn't enough in my book. And during that kiss, there wasn't even the vivid imagery of what her life could be if she chooses Jacob, as in the book. They couldn't do something similar to flashbacks, but instead, flashforwards? They couldn't show the two of them happy? Sigh.
- The other scene was the entire interaction between a tore-up Jacob and a hovering Bella at the end of the movie. Entirely UNbelievable. I felt nothing during that scene. There wasn't even tender affection from Bella towards him, or vice versa. There wasn't her hand to his face, or him holding her close, or her utterance of, "How can we be friends when we love each other like this?" which I thought was pretty heart-wrenching in the book. There wasn't anything that lead me to believe she was in love with him too like book Bella would have been. To me, all she emanated was pity for the boy. And it sucks that the true meaning of the scene was lost in translation. Not much of a deep conversation either. Just Jacob trickling out his last ounces of desperation to keep her, met by her lack of even slightly wanting him back. None of that. It was just sloppily thrown together with a tiny thimble-sized amount of the lines from the whole scene. Jacob just seemed very pathetic and clueless. He was all alone in his pain while his supposed best friend crouched there to pity him, and it shouldn't have felt that way. If only Bella had the longing she was supposed to have for him. If only he spoke of finally accepting Edward as essential in her life, calling him her drug, but referring to himself as her air and sun, someone healthier. She could have agreed as in the book, saying how he broke up the clouds for her for being "his own sun" (as she spoke of him in "New Moon), and he could have said the famous, "The clouds I can handle. But I can't fight with an eclipse" line. My gosh, she doesn't even lean in and kiss his cheek like in the book. Is that really so difficult to pull off? They couldn't have her speak of loving him one more time, when he could have said, "Love you more" before she leaves? If only she had the imagery of her future with him when they kissed, and spoken about it to him, declaring it to be the worst part of not being together. Her movie line of, "I only fought them (her feelings) because I knew they wouldn't change anything," was alright, still from the book in a tweaked way, but it was said in such a factual manner. It's like she's saying, "DUH Jake. THIS is why I didn't tell you I love you." But in the book, she speaks of how she so badly wants to be with him in every way before telling him why she was fighting him so hard. Ugh, dang, even the nice little humorous moment of Jacob saying he'd still take her when her heart stops beating, but it depends on how much she stinks. BLASTED. It was just so wrong. In the movie, it's just fact. But in the book, it's a regrettable fact. Big difference.
- Then came an entire scene that was flat-out MISSING that should have been there. It angers me that it wasn't. I guess since the movie's version of the two big scenes I mentioned were void of Bella's love for someone else, they felt it necessary to leave this one out. But nope, I still hated it. This was a scene between Bella and Edward AFTER the aforementioned moment of her speaking with the wounded Jacob. Of course, this scene would have required some major tears on Kristin's part, which is perhaps another reason why they left it out since she can't seem to have the skill in making herself cry, but enough of that. Anyways, after her visit with Jake, Bella drives away, but pulls off to the side of the road to weep. Literally weep. It was one of the few scenes I appreciated a weepy, tearful Bella. Because it helped prove to me that she really did love that broken Jacob. It showed me that leaving him was the hardest thing in the world for her at that point in time. Of course Edward swoops in and holds her as she cries over her departure from Jacob. It still would have been awesome to see some strong, sadness in response to "breaking up" with Jacob. I personally found it to be the best depiction of what she was feeling about the whole thing. Even Edward, I remember, was very concerned, asking if she's sure she made the right decision. Ugh, I'm looking at the book right now, and damn, it would've been sweet to hear his line of, "If it hurts you so much, how can it possibly be the right thing for you?" It totally peeves me that none of this interaction was in the movie. It would have totally put the whole love triangle thing to a final close. A tearful Bella with hints of regret, but also surety that she is making the right choice. None of that in this movie. Gone, gone, GONE.
- It was disappointing not to see Alice in the final scenes being all giddy for Bella's wedding, but I guess it's not too major a scene. I'm sure the team Edward fans hated not seeing Edward climb all over Bella either. I personally found that scene sorta awkward, probably because I'm not accustomed to Edward being the one to try to "get it on" with Bella in the meadow as he did in the book. I forgave the absence, but I would have been fine if they kept it. What really got to me was Bella's whole stupid speech at the end about her choice not being between Jacob and Edward, and that it was truly a choice between who she should be and who she is. She then rambles on about how strong she is in his world so that's why she feels she belongs there, blah freaking blah. In the book, she never mentions Jacob to him at all, nor does she mention either one of them being her choices. In fact, she speaks nothing of choices. None of that hogwash was in the book. All throughout the whole dang series, as much as it pains me to admit it, Bella declares nothing short of Edward being her whole world. Her love for him is what motivates her to choose to be with him, to make this decision to become a vampire just to stay with him forever. And to have her spew out this nonsense about it being all about herself and nothing at all to do with him was unfitting for how she's supposed to be: Desperately and foolishly in love with EDWARD, not his world because of the strength she feels. I get what they're trying to do, but please. As if leaving things OUT of the book isn't bad enough, now I gotta deal with the stupid stuff they choose to add in for absolutely nothing.
I've already gotten over all of my complaints of this movie. I'm certain I didn't even put all my complaints on here. No matter how many things I've hated, I'll come to terms with it, because quite simply, it is what it is. I'm still getting it on DVD and will likely still watch it over and over. I can't change it. I can only spew about it and move on hehe. I apologize for the length, but no one put a gun to your head or anything to read this! 
Ta-ta.
Recent Comments